English Muffin French Toast Sticks | Mostly Homemade Mom

English Muffin French Toast Sticks

April 21, 2017

This is a sponsored blog; while the views expressed here were genuinely mine, consideration was paid to me by Bays English Muffins to review this product.

These English Muffin French Toast Sticks are super easy and so fun for busy mornings! These are perfect for freezing ahead of time and packing into lunchboxes, too!

English Muffin French Toast Sticks

I know that when you typically think of English muffins, you think of breakfast. I will readily admit, we are English muffin fanatics in the morning. Especially busy mornings! Even when I was a kid, I have very fond memories of crazy school mornings spent eating toasted English muffins with warm melted butter before we were off to school for the day. Of course my kids share the love that I have of them, too! Especially with our favorite Bays English Muffins - seriously, the BEST you can find in the grocery store!

I will say, though, in our family - we honestly enjoy English muffins in all sorts of ways for lunch and dinner as well. There's the classic English muffin pizza of course, but I've been so inspired by Bays chefs' versatile recipe ideas - sandwiches, melts, paninis, and sides. I specifically can't wait to try their Bacon, Beer & Cheddar Muffin Wedges, doesn't that sound delicious? And I'm TOTALLY planning on making some English muffin garlic bread for our next spaghetti night, what a great idea!

French Toast Sticks made with English Muffins

Of course, I could never ignore how wonderfully English muffins pair with breakfast time. If you feel you've been relying on toast and bagels for too long, try switching it up with Bays English Muffins as a change of pace! Maybe set out some new flavored butters, jellies or breakfast sandwich fillings as new topping options. The possibilities are truly endless and everyone in the family gets to create their own.

While perusing all the delicious recipe ideas on Bays website, I simply HAD to try the English Muffin French Toast Sticks recipe for our breakfast-for-dinner night and I am SO EXCITED to share this recipe with you! We fell in love with these so much, I'm actually planning on making a large batch of these and freezing them to put in their lunchboxes. What a great change to the typical sandwich!

yield: 4 servingsprint recipe

English Muffins French Toast Sticks

English muffins dipped in a milk and egg mixture, cooked in a skillet, and sliced into sticks for dipping into maple syrup.
prep time: 20 MINScook time: 20 MINStotal time: 40 mins


  • 4 Bays Original English Muffins, split
  • 3/4 cup milk
  • 3 large eggs
  • 1 tablespoon sugar
  • 1 1/2 teaspoons vanilla extract
  • 1/4 teaspoon ground cinnamon
  • 1 - 2 tablespoons butter, divided
  • maple syrup and fresh fruit for serving


  1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees F.
  2. Place the English muffin halves in a baking pan just large enough to hold them in a single layer.
  3. Beat the milk, eggs, sugar, vanilla extract and cinnamon in a medium bowl. Pour the mixture over the English muffins, turning to coat. Let stand 20 minutes, turning once.
  4. Heat a large nonstick skillet or griddle over medium heat. Melt half of the butter and add 4 muffin halves. Cook until the bottoms are lightly golden, about 3-4 minutes. Turn the muffin halves over and cook until lightly golden, about 3-4 minutes longer. Transfer the French toast to an ovenproof pan and hold in the preheated oven. Repeat with remaining muffin halves and butter.
  5. Cut each English muffin half into three even lengthwise strips. Serve with a small ramekin of warm maple syrup for dipping and fresh fruit.
Created using The Recipes Generator

My kids honestly went absolutely nuts for these french toast sticks - I actually had to make them seconds because they had polished them off so quickly! Next time, I plan on using Bays Sourdough, Multi-Grain, and Honey Wheat varieties to see how it changes up the french toast flavor. 

On your next shopping trip, pick up your package of Bays English Muffins in the refrigerated section of the grocery store next to the milk and eggs. Also, be sure click here for more english muffin recipe ideas as well as a store locator.

With more than 80 years of family tradition of their authentic, original recipe - you can now find Bays at your local Tops Friendly Markets. To celebrate, you can find $1 off coupons on each package at Tops. There's also a fun sweepstakes on Bays Facebook page, be sure and enter to win an entire case of English muffins - that's 12 packages! They also regularly share recipe ideas there and fun weekly pop quizzes. 

English Muffin French Toast

What's your favorite way to enjoy English muffins? Leave your ideas in the comment section below this post!

Post Comment
Post a Comment